Polyamory Predicaments: Dealing with Partners and Opening a Marriage

posted in: Dirty Talk Advice, Home Page | 0

Dirty Talk Advice ColumnPolyamory. Otherwise known as the practice, state or ability of having more than one loving relationship at the same time, with the full knowledge and consent of all partners involved. It seems as if the polygamous concept is a particularly hot topic at the moment. After centuries, if not millennia, of the monogamous relationship model being presented as the de facto way to do relationships, the tides are slowly shifting. More and more people are exploring and undertaking alternative relationship models.

Today’s column tackles the topic of polyamory and some of the predicaments that can come along with it. Let’s get started, shall we?


Why Is My Wife Always Cold Towards My Girlfriends?

“My wife and I have been together for 14 years now. We have always been polyamorous, but recently we have hit a rocky patch in our relationship. I am now with my fourth partner other than my wife and my wife has not liked any of them. She is never rude, she just is cold and distant and unfriendly. At first I thought that she just didn’t like my first girlfriend, but she didn’t like the second one or the third one either.

I am now with my fourth partner and am deeply in love. I want to spend the rest of my life with her as well as my wife. But I am starting to realize that my wife is probably not ever going to warm up to her. What can I do? I am always friendly with her partners, why can’t she do the same for mine?”–Poly Predicament

Parallel PolyamoryI actually went through a very similar experience myself PP. For many years my husband’s girlfriend lived with us and she simply could not stand me. She was passingly civil to me, but it was the absolute bare minimum. She never engaged me in conversation. Never made eye contact. Never asked how my day was. She was a monogamous person in denial, trying to live as poly and hating it. Despite many attempts to address and resolve the situation, it never got any better and eventually she had to move out.

In your case, it sounds as if your wife enjoys being polyamorous but is never going to be friendly or welcoming to your other partners. If you are with your fourth girlfriend and she has treated all of them the same way, this does not appear to be a behavior she is particularly inclined to change.

There is no right way to poly. I am someone who prefers kitchen table polyamory. I like to have all of my partners around, being engaging and friendly with each other. However, that style of polyamory does not work for everyone. Your wife may be more comfortable practicing parallel poly. This seems like the situation to me. Your wife is okay with the two of you having relationships outside the marriage but has no desire to interact with the people that you date.

If having your partners interact is important to you, your only real option in this situation is to sit down with your wife and talk about your desires. I’ve found one of the best methods for these types of conversations is to write down your feelings in advance and what specific topics or incidents you want to discuss. Having these notes provides the benefit of being able to stay on topic if the conversation goes sideways or becomes heated. Once your notes are prepared, share them with your wife in a nonaccusatory way. After that, the ball is in her court.

Hopefully she can hear what you have to say and take it upon herself to be friendlier to your girlfriend. If she is unwilling to change her actions or discounts what you have to say, you are in a tricky position. Much like my husband’s girlfriend was never “technically” unfriendly to me, all she did was freeze me out and refuse to engage with me, there is a high possibly that your wife will continue to do the same. If that is the case, there is not much that you can do. You can’t force her to be friendly and engaging.

If, after your conversation with your wife, you find that this is not the way she prefers to practice polyamory, do not initiate interactions between your wife and your girlfriend. Given space, your wife may warm up to your girlfriend but accept the fact that she might not. If that is how are things end up panning out, don’t try and create situations were the two of them have to spend a lot of time together. That generally increases tension, not decreases it.


How Do I Open Up My Marriage?

“While I am happily married, I am also certain that I am polyamorous. How do I go about opening up my marriage? I love my husband and do not want to hurt him, but I also am feeling trapped and stifled in my monogamous marriage. How do I tell my husband about my urges to explore polyamory without it affecting my marriage?”–Married And Poly

Opening up MarriageThe truth is, there is no guarantee that this will not affect your marriage. All you can do is have an open and honest discussion with your husband about your needs. How he chooses to react to that discussion is somewhat beyond your control. You can present your needs in as calm and clear a manner as possible, while attempting to deescalate any hurt feelings that might arise, but there is no guarantee that he will not feel hurt.

On the other hand, he might also have polyamorous desires and has been afraid to tell you! You will never know until you cross that bridge. He could be wildly receptive to hearing about your needs and it could be the start of a whole new chapter in your relationship. There is only one way to find out and that is by having the discussion.

There are some steps to take in order to ensure that the discussion about opening up your marriage goes as smoothly as possible. Do it in a neutral setting with consideration taken that he is not having a bad day or stressing about other things before you attempt to have this discussion with him. Be sure to build in time to process any feelings of rejection that might come up for him. Explain to him why you are feeling the desire to explore your polyamorous wiring without creating an environment where he feels like he is not good enough to satisfy your needs.

If, after taking all of these steps, the discussion goes poorly, you are left with two options. Either accept being a polyamorous person in a monogamous relationship or tackle whether exploring your polyamory side is important enough to you that you will not be able to stay in a monogamous relationship. People that are in denial of their wiring, be it kinky or bisexual or polyamorous, can sometimes enter into relationships thinking that they will be able to continue to deny their wiring. Such attempts rarely work out and often end in heartbreak.

If your monogamous marriage does not survive your attempt to open it up, do not enter into any other monogamous relationships in the future. You will only be doing yourself and your monogamous partner a disservice.


I’m New To Polyamory, How Do Interact With My Boyfriend’s Other Partners?

“I am a monogamous person that is currently dating a polyamorous person. While I am deeply in love with them, I have never done anything like this before. They have other partners and I am finding it challenging to learn how to interact with them. I have never shared a boyfriend with other women. While nothing that would derail our relationship has come up yet, I worry that day will come to pass. How do I successfully navigate my first poly relationship?”–Poly Newbie

Contemplating PolyamoryWhile it is not impossible for a monogamous person to date a polyamorous person, it certainly presents some challenges. I know of some people that successfully managed to pull off such a situation, but it is less common. Generally the monogamous person, despite believing in the beginning that they would be able to deal with their partner’s polyamory ends up feeling too slighted and jealous to be able to continue the relationship.

Some people certainly manage to make it work but the fact that you already find yourself concerned enough to reach out to me gives me the impression that you are currently having second thoughts. Even polyamorous people can find themselves needing to process jealousy when their partners are spending time with another partner. Such a situation is infinitely compounded when it is a monogamous person trying to process that jealousy.

As for interacting with his other partners, there is no right way to go about it. It all depends on what is most comfortable to you and works for your and your boyfriend’s relationship. You can be open and friendly to them or you don’t need to interact with them at all. There is a very wide spectrum in which people practice polyamory. Everything from dont ask don’t tell relationships to relationships where everyone shares partners. The important thing is that you need to respect his other relationships. Allow them the time and attention needed to stay health, just as his other relationships should provide that in return to yours.

The only way to know what kind of situation is going to work for you is to go through it. Maybe you will find that you have a knack for it that you were unaware of. You could even end up becoming friends with his other partners! However, if you find yourself spending nights waiting by the phone and looking at the calendar while imagining all of the fun your boyfriend is having with his other girlfriends, your relationship probably is not going to go the distance. I am proud of you for at least attempting something new and getting out of your comfort zone. Best of luck and I hope everything works out!

Keep it Kinky My Friends,
RDG

Want to add your own insight to the conversation? Leave a comment below.
Have a question that you want answered in the Dirty Talk Advice Column? Contact Rain here.

Keep these columns coming.
Patreon LogoSupport Rain on Patreon

OR

Paypal donate button

Love this post? Share it with your friends!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments