The truth is, humans have never been particularly good at monogamy. For various reasons, societies keep trying to create monogamous relationship structures, with various levels of success. However, humans being humans, we keep coloring outside the “approved” lines. While we might not be particularly good at monogamy in practice, we keep trying for it in principle–and often falling short.
Which brings us to our modern day. What is undeniable is that the practice of polyamory is becoming more widely discussed and less banished to the shadows. As polyamory becomes more widely practiced and discussed, there are inevitable speed bumps to be addressed. One of the largest is how poly looks during the holiday season. Today’s topic comes courtesy of PHP, who has some uncertainty over how to ethically address poly during this time of year. Let’s get started, shall we?
“I am happily poly and have been for the past two years, with two partners that I care for deeply. We all get along and things are going very well. My question is how do you make sure that nobody feels excluded over the holidays? Do I spend Christmas/New Years Eve with Partner A or Partner B? Whichever partner I am with that particular day means that the other partner gets excluded and both of their families are clear that they don’t want us showing up as a triad. I want to respect their wishes. What is the right way to handle this?”–Poly Holidays Predicament
Unfortunately, Western Society Isn’t Set Up For Poly Dynamics
Despite the fact that humans keep failing at monogamy, we keep trying, and our society is set up for twos, not threes (or mores). Where do poly people sit at restaurants, the theater, inside cars? How do they handle holidays or office parties? Once you become poly, you realize just how significant seating arrangements can become. If you are dating two different people and are not out at your workplace as poly, which partner do you bring to the office Christmas party? Whichever person you pick, the other partner can feel excluded and slighted. It easily gets rather complex.
Here is where my favorite tool comes into play–communication. Without communication we are just fumbling around in the dark and hoping for the best. It is a recipe for disaster and stubbed toes. Your letter says that you and your partners get along, but it does not specify if you are practicing kitchen table poly or Vee type polyamory. With Vee type polyamory, if you are the hinge between the two relationships and you are dating both of your partners but they are not dating each other, then yes, the holidays can get a little tricky. I am going to hazard a guess that you are in a Vee style situation and answer accordingly.
If both partner A and partner B’s families have made it clear that they are not comfortable with their child’s partner’s other partner showing up for the holiday gathering, their wishes need to be respected. At least it sounds like they are all aware of the relationship situation, even if they don’t personally approve. This honesty about the situation is further down the road then some people ever get. Once the option of poly holidays with your partner’s parents has been taken off of the table, you need to look at your other options.
Check In With Your Partners About Their Feelings
Not everybody approaches the holidays in the same way. For some people, spending it with family is incredibly important. For others, they attach a lot less significance to the whole thing. Your first step is to find out if both partner A and partner B are very invested in having you by their side for Christmas or New Years. You just might find out that they either don’t care or would rather spend the holidays with you as opposed to their family. You will never know until you sit down and have that discussion with them. If you talk with both of them and find out that one or the other does not care particularly about having you with them on a certain day, problem solved!
If both partner A and partner B are deeply committed to having you by their side during their family gathering, your safest bet is to split up the day and spend half of the day with each partner. That way they can get the family time desired without bringing up poly politics. In the end, polyamory is more about scheduling and communication and less about the rampant banging monogamous people seem convinced we are doing at all times. I spend a lot more time scheduling then I ever do having sex.
Consider Having Your Own Separate Celebration
Another option is to skip the holiday gatherings at both partner A and partner B’s locations and hold your own with the two of them. If it works out in terms of scheduling and family feelings, this tends to be the option that I advocate for the most. This is the best way to ensure that nobody ends up feeling excluded. Also there aren’t any awkward conversations over the dining room table from a drunk uncle Harry who doesn’t understand your particular relationship structure and keeps muttering under his breath about “kids these days.”
No matter how it plays out, the core of it is communication. The sooner you sit down and communicate, and the calmer and more effective your communication is, the less your chances of something going off the rails. Get an idea of what everybody wants and is hoping for and then proceed accordingly. Best of luck and a happy holiday season to all three of you!




